Quantcast

Review: L’Oreal Infallible Plumping Lip Gloss

by Amber on July 31, 2009

in lip gloss,makeup,new products,product reviews,Uncategorized

From the moment I saw Eva Longoria’s lips in this L’Oréal ad, my mind went into a trance-like state where it repeated “MUST HAVE LIPS MUST HAVE LIPS” over and over again until I tore out the ad and stared at it.  I thought that somehow by willpower I would glance in the mirror and my lips would be that exact shade of pink.  I guess we all know where I’m going with this.  It didn’t happen like that.

If you want to give it a shot, pick up L’Oréal’s new Infallible Plumping Lip Gloss in #206 Plumped Rose and see if you can do it as much justice as Eva does!  I was in the Honda service department checking out earlier this week and my service guy had this BEAUTIFUL autograph of Eva framed behind him and I immediately said “John, how did you get Eva Longoria to give YOU an autograph?”

“Didn’t you see her?  She was sitting right next to you in the waiting area.”

For a second he almost had me, I’m very gullible– seriously, and we joke like that.  It was odd because I’d been testing this gloss and out of the sky comes a photo of Eva, almost like HELLLOOOOOO!  Just review it already, you’ll never have lips like mine, get over it!

So here ya go…

8 new shades round out this collection and I honestly think I couldn’t have had a better range of everyday-wearable shades to choose from to test.  Plumped Tawny, Plumped Rose, and Plumped Plum were all very friendly colors that I think everyone could put on and look great in.  There are reds, browns, and corals to be had too– but you can’t go wrong with these.  It’s pretty much what you see is what you get:

But did my lips turn out like Eva’s in Plumped Rose?

If we factor in things like lighting, her skin’s undertone, and the makeup artist than I would say yes!  But it wasn’t realistic for me to expect that anyway– I just like making myself miserable apparently!  I absolutely love the glass-like shine these give off, and they stay that way for quite some time.  Not quite for 6 hours, and that’s okay because I think we’re all becoming very extreme in our expectations.  10 years from now, Toyota will have a car that’s ignition is started by putting your lip gloss wand in to it so you don’t have to carry key fobs anymore at this rate.  And if that really does happen, I’d like to state that I thought of it first!  With the amount of gabbing and sipping that goes on with me, 6 hours would be AMAZING, but more realistic is about 3.  Anything over 3 is a miracle of epic proportions at this point, in that case Infallible Plumping Gloss passes the test.  In terms of color retention, it also passes.  Even though, when I sip on a beverage a little gloss comes off– the color is still very apparent and all is not lost.  The texture of the gloss itself will probably be the deciding factor for you but I think we need to revisit our expectations when we consider it.  On the lip, it can feel somewhat tacky.  Not like your lips will stick together and you won’t be able to say a word (wait– another novel idea of mine!), but it’s a little bit gummier than what you may be used to.  It’s not like you’re going to be setting up a kissing booth at the county fair, or are you?  The scent/taste is almost a little on the perfume-y side for a minute but quickly dissipates into nothing.  I don’t mind it at all.  The applicator on the wand itself is KILLER.

Not your typical doe foot, and I love that because the coverage is so much more even.  You can detail your cupid’s cusp and the corners of lips so much more precisely with this little heart-shaped pad.  This deposits almost a film of color on your lips that should last a few hours like I experienced.  Woo hoo!  So maybe I’m not Eva, but I think I came close enough all things considered to warrant an Infallible Plumping purchase.

  • http://milo.com Marina

    I love Burt Bee’s lip shimmer but am bummed that it has no SPF. :( Is Spf8 enough? Has anyone tried this one with spf?

  • http://nouveaucheap.blogspot.com Recessionista

    OF COURSE, I choose to review every new L’Oreal product *except* for this one which, after reading your amazing review, I now *must* own!

    All three colors look gorgeous on your lips and the doe-foot is seriously making me want to jump in my car and drive to the drugstore as I type this. Seriously, your reviews are THE BEST and you’ve totally sold me on this (plus you made me laugh while doing it!). xo

  • http://bestthingsinbeauty.blogspot.com/ Charlestongirl

    What a hoot! Great review! I love L’Oreal’s lip colors, but not their actual products. I hate the fact that they are heavy on the fragrance. I can’t get past that. I wish the scent would disappear for me, but it doesn’t. So, I just stopped buying them.

    I checked these out at my local CVS and passed on them knowing they would smell like drugstore perfume. I have to say, though, that if you can stand the tackiness and fragrance, the Plumped Plum and Plumped Rose are very flattering on your lips. The glassy shine is superb. Don’t worry about that famous gal having a leg-up (so to speak) on you. She had studio lighting, professional artists, and some help from photo editors – not to mention those false eyelashes.

    So, please let us know if you leap or leave.

  • http://beautyjunkiesunite.com Amber

    Heya girls, you are too funny!

    Charlestongirl, I know what you mean. Sometimes you just can’t overlook fragrance… it’s one of those things that people can be sensitive to no matter how little/much it influences someone else’s nose! Thanks for the compliment :) Fall is going to be a HUGE red lip season so I’ll probably pick up the Infallible red. Eva is so gorge *sigh*

    Recessionista! Please tell me you didn’t break in the middle of the night and run to a 24 hour Rite Aid. I see you in a few of these, but seriously they will still be there in the morning lol :)

    xo
    Amber

  • Emma

    I tried one of the Infallible glosses last year, before they had their new plumping formula, and I thought it smelled like cold medicine! Seriously, it was a very sweet scent that had almost a medicinal quality to it. It made me feel ill! I wonder if they’ve changed the scent at all, because that would be the factor that could lead me to try one of these. I love the color of the Plumped Tawny gloss but not enough to endure that smell again!

  • http://nouveaucheap.blogspot.com Recessionista

    LOL! Would you believe there are no 24-hr Rite-Aids in my area? I don’t know if this is a blessing or a curse. lol. But I did go to CVS yesterday and guess what? The display was wiped out! The only shades remaining were colors I knew wouldn’t work for me so…now the hunt is on! :)

  • http://beautyjunkiesunite.com Amber

    Hi Emma,

    I totally understand! Sometimes you just can’t let some things slide in a product, and scents are such personal things that could really sway someone… I wonder if L’Oreal is curious about this and if there’s something that can be done since it’s a pretty common desire from readers!

    xo
    Amber

  • http://beautyjunkiesunite.com Amber

    Hey R!

    Hard to tell! Is it telling you to buy it, or not buy it since they’re all gone? lol I rocked Plumped Rose yesterday and I got several compliments ;) Are you looking for the Plum?

    xo
    Amber

  • http://nouveaucheap.blogspot.com Recessionista

    Actually I was looking for all three! lol. I don’t think I’d buy all three at once but your pics sold me on all three shades and I wanted to see ‘em in person. But of course they were all gone. I’m on a quest though, because of that darn applicator. xo

  • http://beautyjunkiesunite.com Amber

    Mornin’ R! That applicator is flippin’ sweet!!!

    xo
    Amber

  • Bunny

    Okay, so i saw the ad and like an idiot, i bought the gloss. I noticed that most people talked about the colors, the staying power, etc. But, nobody said anything about the “plumping” part. It didn’t do anything at all to my lips other than make them very, very sticky. Yes, i like the color (i bought rose) and will wear the gloss (only so i don’t feel so bad about wasting my money) but i would have been happier had it just been called Infallable lip gloss. Why lie about being a plumper? I’m so tired of being lied to by advertisers. It’s just like those anti-puff eye roller things…worthless. Sigh

  • http://beautyjunkiesunite.com Amber

    Hey Bunny :)

    I totally see your point! Looking back it seems like I didn’t go into that part too much unfortunately :( I went and grabbed a tube from my vanity a sec ago to refresh my memory on the “plumping” performance! You’re right, it’s not exactly the best lip plumper in the universe. It doesn’t have those almost immediate effects where your lips’ blood circulation is stimulated and you get a little bit of swelling like most other plumpers on the market, so in a sense… I think it lets me down in that perspective. On the other hand, what I do notice is that due to the formula’s texture and the film it applies over the lip surface, it makes it seem like the lines are less noticeable than they really are in my lips– and the little light reflective particles have the potential to give off an optical illusion of fuller lips. But I agree with you– they aren’t exactly “plumper”. So perhaps another choice of words would have been better in this instance. It can be frustrating at times, I absolutely agree! Especially when our experiences with products and our views on their performances are so subjective. I’m sad to hear you’re bummed! But I know what you mean girlie!

    xo
    Amber

Previous post:

Next post:


Wordpress migrations by Blog Movers