Review & Swatches: Too Faced Natural at Night Sexy & Sultry Neutral Eyeshadow Collection

Too Faced rightfully takes ownership of their seat at the cool kids’ table this spring, by joining in on the nude/neutral/naked eyeshadow theme that so many brands are producing. Now wait—before you say, “Not another one!”, I have to tell you—there are some great shades inside this little baby. You owe it to yourself to at least check it out!

Natural at Night takes nine neutral shadows and dolls them up a little, making them worthy of many enjoyable nights out on the town. A great mix of shimmering, glittering, and matte shades, each one is a star! Create nighttime, classic, and fashionable looks by switching it up—or you can just use the handy dandy how-to cards that are enclosed for inspiration.

More photos, swatches, and details… 

The shade breakdown…

Full Moon — glittery light bronze
Nightcap — shimmering medium bronze
Cocoa Star — deep matte cocoa
Night Light — glittery blush
After Hours — medium mauve shimmer
Eclipse — deep mauve shimmer
Spotlight — matte bisque
Moon Stone — shimmering brass with olive undertones
Night Fever — deep golden brown glitter

While I experienced some glitter fallout with Night Light, the quality is impressively consistent across the palette. Smooth to the touch, and without a hint of chalkiness, all nine shades were easy to blend.

Night Light, After Hours, and Eclipse

Bottom Line: These are all warm neutrals that are anything but boring. The shades are pigment-rich, long lasting, and are super buttery smooth. Using the eyeshadows inside Natural at Night is a real treat.

Price & Availability: $36;,, ULTA

An editorial sample was provided by the company and evaluated to determine our opinion of the product in this post. Please see the Disclosures page for further information regarding our policies for using editorial samples.
  • Bobbie Crippen

    These are some fantastic colors. There isn’t a one that I wouldn’t use. COVET! “Two Faced, Natural At Night” is absolutely unique. It will be a go to pallett.

  • Marty

    This is gorgeous!!! Which would you recommend between this one and the natural eye palette? I can only get one and I already have the UD Naked palette…

  • Amber

    Hi Marty! I would probably choose this one because the shades are a little bit more amped up than Naked 😉

  • Ashley H (@Couponmomfl)

    I really like that palette. I tend to wear those colors alot when I wear eye makeup! They look really good on.

  • shauna

    I’m loving these! I love a bit (or a lot) of shimmer!

  • Eugenia

    Hello! Wanted to say hi to a fellow February too faced beauty blogger! I love the colors in here, they are so pigmented!

  • Amber

    Hi Eugenia! Congratulations! :)

  • Laura

    Wow this looks so pretty so tempted to buy it myself:) xx

  • Cortney

    I loved the Natural at Night colors. This works especially well for me because I have hazel eyes :)

    Great job!